The Shanghai stock market crash in the late Qing Dynasty, th...
The Shanghai stock market crash in 1910 during the Qing Dynasty and the stock market crashes in new China in 2008 and 2015, although occurring in different historical contexts, share some core characteristics and mechanisms. Here are their main similarities:
1. Market speculation overheating
• 1910: Speculative activities were rampant, investors blindly chased prices higher, the stock market was manipulated by large capital, resulting in artificially inflated stock prices.
• 2008: There was a real estate bubble and speculative trading in derivative products in the global financial market. Investors borrowed heavily, leading to a sharp increase in financial system risks, and ultimately the collapse of the real estate market triggered a global financial crisis.
• 2015: The Chinese stock market experienced a rapid increase period, with many retail investors entering the market, driving up stock prices. Some investors also leveraged funds for margin trading, leading to a market bubble.
2. The Role of Leverage and Financing
• 1910: Many investors used loans for stock trading. When the stock market fell, they were unable to repay the debts, intensifying market panic.
• 2008: Banks and investment institutions heavily invested in real estate and financial derivatives through high leverage. When the market declined, they could not manage the risk exposure, resulting in numerous bankruptcies.
• 2015: Investors widely used finance and securities lending, leveraging funds for trading. Market volatility amplified the risks of these leveraged investments. Once the market declined, leveraged funds were liquidated on a large scale, causing stock prices to plummet.
3. Insufficient Market Regulation
• 1910: The Shanghai stock market lacked effective regulation, leading to market manipulation. Speculators exploited market loopholes for speculation.
• 2008: The risks in financial derivatives and subprime mortgage markets were underestimated. Regulatory authorities failed to timely detect and control systemic risks in the financial market.
• 2015: The regulatory framework of the Chinese stock market was not complete enough, especially when investors used leveraged funds, they failed to timely control the excessive influx of funds, underestimating market risks.
4. Instability of the economic environment
• 1910: At that time, the corrupt and incompetent Qing government, economic recession, turbulent domestic and foreign situations, sharp social contradictions, all affected investors' confidence.
• 2008: Global economic growth slowed down, the USA subprime mortgage crisis triggered instability in the global financial system, eventually leading to a global stock market crash.
• 2015: China's economic growth slowed down, investors worried about the unclear economic outlook, combined with the gradual emergence of market bubbles, which triggered a confidence collapse.
5. Contagion of panic emotions
• 1910: Stock market plunges triggered market panic, with investors rushing to sell stocks, exacerbating the market downturn.
• 2008: As Lehman Brothers collapsed, global financial markets experienced panic emotions, funds were withdrawn from the market in large quantities, causing a stock market plunge.
• 2015: After a rapid decline in the stock market, investors lost confidence and started selling stocks, leading to significant short-term volatility in the stock market.
6. Systemic Risk Spreading
• 1910: The stock market crash led to the paralysis of Shanghai's financial system, with multiple financial institutions going bankrupt and causing severe economic damage.
• 2008: The financial crisis spread from the USA's real estate market to the global financial market, putting enormous pressure on the banking system and causing a global economic recession.
• 2015: Volatility in the Chinese stock market triggered concerns in the global market, leading to fluctuations in Asian and European stock markets. The fragility of the Chinese financial market affected the confidence of global investors.
7. Similarity in Policy Interventions
• 1910: After the stock disaster, the Qing government and local financial institutions in Shanghai were forced to intervene. However, due to inadequate financial supervision and policy systems, the effects were limited.
• 2008: Governments and central banks of various countries implemented large-scale market support measures, such as the USA's quantitative easing policy and massive financial assistance plans, to stabilize the financial markets.
• 2015: The Chinese government intervened quickly by suspending IPOs, prohibiting major shareholders from reducing their holdings, and using state funds to buy stocks to stabilize the market.
Summary
Although the stock market crashes of 1910 occurred in the early capital markets of China, they bear significant similarities to the stock market crashes of 2008 and 2015 in speculation, leveraged finance, inadequate regulation, market panic, etc. These stock market crashes all reveal the fragility of financial markets and the profound impact on the economy, society, and the global financial system when markets spiral out of control.
Any financial system, once manipulated excessively, will bring about unforeseeable disasters, revealing the unpredictable nature of human behavior. When disaster strikes, human nature will be fully exposed, with people trampling over each other in a desperate rush.
1. Market speculation overheating
• 1910: Speculative activities were rampant, investors blindly chased prices higher, the stock market was manipulated by large capital, resulting in artificially inflated stock prices.
• 2008: There was a real estate bubble and speculative trading in derivative products in the global financial market. Investors borrowed heavily, leading to a sharp increase in financial system risks, and ultimately the collapse of the real estate market triggered a global financial crisis.
• 2015: The Chinese stock market experienced a rapid increase period, with many retail investors entering the market, driving up stock prices. Some investors also leveraged funds for margin trading, leading to a market bubble.
2. The Role of Leverage and Financing
• 1910: Many investors used loans for stock trading. When the stock market fell, they were unable to repay the debts, intensifying market panic.
• 2008: Banks and investment institutions heavily invested in real estate and financial derivatives through high leverage. When the market declined, they could not manage the risk exposure, resulting in numerous bankruptcies.
• 2015: Investors widely used finance and securities lending, leveraging funds for trading. Market volatility amplified the risks of these leveraged investments. Once the market declined, leveraged funds were liquidated on a large scale, causing stock prices to plummet.
3. Insufficient Market Regulation
• 1910: The Shanghai stock market lacked effective regulation, leading to market manipulation. Speculators exploited market loopholes for speculation.
• 2008: The risks in financial derivatives and subprime mortgage markets were underestimated. Regulatory authorities failed to timely detect and control systemic risks in the financial market.
• 2015: The regulatory framework of the Chinese stock market was not complete enough, especially when investors used leveraged funds, they failed to timely control the excessive influx of funds, underestimating market risks.
4. Instability of the economic environment
• 1910: At that time, the corrupt and incompetent Qing government, economic recession, turbulent domestic and foreign situations, sharp social contradictions, all affected investors' confidence.
• 2008: Global economic growth slowed down, the USA subprime mortgage crisis triggered instability in the global financial system, eventually leading to a global stock market crash.
• 2015: China's economic growth slowed down, investors worried about the unclear economic outlook, combined with the gradual emergence of market bubbles, which triggered a confidence collapse.
5. Contagion of panic emotions
• 1910: Stock market plunges triggered market panic, with investors rushing to sell stocks, exacerbating the market downturn.
• 2008: As Lehman Brothers collapsed, global financial markets experienced panic emotions, funds were withdrawn from the market in large quantities, causing a stock market plunge.
• 2015: After a rapid decline in the stock market, investors lost confidence and started selling stocks, leading to significant short-term volatility in the stock market.
6. Systemic Risk Spreading
• 1910: The stock market crash led to the paralysis of Shanghai's financial system, with multiple financial institutions going bankrupt and causing severe economic damage.
• 2008: The financial crisis spread from the USA's real estate market to the global financial market, putting enormous pressure on the banking system and causing a global economic recession.
• 2015: Volatility in the Chinese stock market triggered concerns in the global market, leading to fluctuations in Asian and European stock markets. The fragility of the Chinese financial market affected the confidence of global investors.
7. Similarity in Policy Interventions
• 1910: After the stock disaster, the Qing government and local financial institutions in Shanghai were forced to intervene. However, due to inadequate financial supervision and policy systems, the effects were limited.
• 2008: Governments and central banks of various countries implemented large-scale market support measures, such as the USA's quantitative easing policy and massive financial assistance plans, to stabilize the financial markets.
• 2015: The Chinese government intervened quickly by suspending IPOs, prohibiting major shareholders from reducing their holdings, and using state funds to buy stocks to stabilize the market.
Summary
Although the stock market crashes of 1910 occurred in the early capital markets of China, they bear significant similarities to the stock market crashes of 2008 and 2015 in speculation, leveraged finance, inadequate regulation, market panic, etc. These stock market crashes all reveal the fragility of financial markets and the profound impact on the economy, society, and the global financial system when markets spiral out of control.
Any financial system, once manipulated excessively, will bring about unforeseeable disasters, revealing the unpredictable nature of human behavior. When disaster strikes, human nature will be fully exposed, with people trampling over each other in a desperate rush.
Disclaimer: Community is offered by Moomoo Technologies Inc. and is for educational purposes only.
Read more
Comment
Sign in to post a comment
