Judge Kim found that Giamatteo’s behavior, while potentially uncomfortable, did not meet the threshold for severe harassment or wage discrimination. The ruling, dismissing the claims with prejudice, prevents them from being refiled on the same grounds. BlackBerry spokesperson Camilla Scassellati Sforzolini expressed satisfaction with the court's decision, while Sandhu's attorney, Maria Bourn, criticized it and hinted at a possible appeal. Despite the dismissals, BlackBerry still faces wrongful termination claims from Sandhu, which the company contests as "baseless."