MCB Withdraws Proposal to Acquire Whitestone Due to Whitestone Board's Entrenchment and Refusal to Engage
MCB Withdraws Proposal to Acquire Whitestone Due to Whitestone Board's Entrenchment and Refusal to Engage
Calls on Independent Trustees of Whitestone to Initiate Strategic Review Process to Maximize Value for Whitestone Shareholders
呼吁怀特斯通的独立受托人启动战略审查程序,为怀特斯通股东实现价值最大化
Reminds Trustees of the Whitestone Board's Fiduciary Duties
提醒受托人注意怀特斯通委员会的信托责任
BALTIMORE, Nov. 18, 2024 /PRNewswire/ -- MCB Real Estate ("MCB"), a leading commercial real estate developer and investment management firm with a diverse nationwide portfolio and approximately $3 billion in AUM, today sent a letter to the Board of Trustees of Whitestone REIT (NYSE: WSR) ("Whitestone") withdrawing MCB's previously announced proposal to acquire the company.
巴尔的摩,2024年11月18日 /PRNewswire/ — 拥有多元化全国投资组合和资产管理规模约30亿美元的领先商业房地产开发商和投资管理公司McB Real Estate(“MCB”)今天致函怀特斯通房地产投资信托基金(纽约证券交易所代码:WSR)(“Whitestone”)董事会,撤回了MCB先前宣布的收购该公司的提议。
MCB sent the following letter to the Whitestone Board:
McB 向怀特斯通董事会发出了以下信函:
November 18, 2024
2024年11月18日
Board of Trustees
C/O David K. Holeman
Whitestone REIT
2600 S. Gessner Rd, Suite 500
Houston, TX 77063
受托人委员会
C/O David k. Holeman
怀特斯通房地产投资信托基金
南盖斯纳路 2600 号,500 号套房
德克萨斯州休斯顿 77063
Dear Whitestone REIT Board of Trustees:
尊敬的怀特斯通房地产投资信托基金董事会:
MCB Real Estate ("MCB" or "we") delivered an attractive, fully-financed proposal to the Whitestone Board to acquire Whitestone for $15 per share in an all-cash transaction. Our proposal would maximize value to Whitestone's shareholders, delivering immediate and certain value in the form of a 14.5% premium to Whitestone's share price prior to our initial proposal on June 3, 2024, and a 61.8% premium to Whitestone's unaffected share price prior to the rumored Fortress proposal on October 26, 2023. We have made repeated efforts to engage with the Whitestone Board over the last several months, but each of those attempts has been summarily rebuffed. The Board's refusal to grant due diligence, engage in any meaningful discussions, or commence a strategic alternatives process is not consistent with its duties and indicates a boardroom culture of entrenchment.
McB Real Estate(“MCB” 或 “我们”)向怀特斯通董事会提交了一份有吸引力的、资金充足的提案,要求以每股15美元的全现金交易收购怀特斯通。我们的提案将为怀特斯通的股东实现价值最大化,在2024年6月3日我们最初的提案之前,以比怀特斯通的股价溢价14.5%的形式立即实现一定的价值,在2023年10月26日传闻中的要塞提案之前,比怀特斯通未受影响的股价高出61.8%。在过去的几个月中,我们一再努力与怀特斯通委员会进行接触,但每一次尝试都遭到断然拒绝。董事会拒绝进行尽职调查、参与任何有意义的讨论或启动战略备选方案,这与其职责不符,也表明了董事会的牢固文化。
While we continue to believe our proposal is the best path forward for shareholders, our attempts to engage have been rebuffed at every turn, so we are withdrawing our proposal to acquire Whitestone at this time.
尽管我们仍然认为我们的提议是股东的最佳前进方向,但我们的参与尝试每时每刻都遭到拒绝,因此我们目前正在撤回收购怀特斯通的提议。
This is not a decision taken lightly. We are disappointed and disturbed at the Board's intransigence, entrenchment and apparent self-interest. The Company's recent public comments make it painfully clear that the Board is not open-minded or even willing to give real consideration to opportunities to advance shareholders' best interests.
这不是一个轻率的决定。我们对董事会的顽固态度、根深蒂固和明显的自身利益感到失望和不安。该公司最近的公开评论清楚地表明,董事会并不开放,甚至不愿意真正考虑促进股东最大利益的机会。
Just a few weeks ago, Whitestone defended its entrenched position with unsupported and unrealistic claims of Whitestone's greater hypothetical "intrinsic value." Notably, however, that value was not actually provided, proven or even explained. Whitestone also attempted to rationalize the Board's refusal to consider alternatives by relying on a period of stock price outperformance that was driven by multiple acquisition rumors and proposals, including ours, that inflated Whitestone's share price.
就在几周前,怀特斯通为其根深蒂固的地位辩护,声称怀特斯通具有更大的假设 “内在价值”,这种说法毫无根据且不切实际。但是,值得注意的是,这种价值实际上并未提供、证实甚至没有得到解释。怀特斯通还试图通过一段时期的股价跑赢大盘来合理化董事会拒绝考虑替代方案的理由,这段时间是由包括我们的在内的多个收购传闻和提案所推动的,这些传闻和提议抬高了怀特斯通的股价。
When pressed on whether the Board is open to opportunities to enhance value on Whitestone's third quarter 2024 earnings call, Whitestone CEO David Holeman falsely asserted that the Board is actively looking at strategic options. Further, he seemingly didn't even understand what such a process to maximize value would actually entail. When asked, he said:
在怀特斯通的2024年第三季度财报电话会议上,当被问及董事会是否愿意接受提高价值的机会时,怀特斯通首席执行官戴维·霍尔曼错误地断言董事会正在积极考虑战略选择。此外,他似乎甚至不明白这种实现价值最大化的过程到底意味着什么。当被问到时,他说:
"I would tell you that our board reviews the best things for shareholders all the time. So we are actively looking at what are the best ways to add value, what are the best ways to produce a return to our shareholders. So I think we are actively doing that just like we should, and so I'm not sure I'm clear with your question."
“我想告诉你,我们的董事会一直在审查对股东来说最好的东西。因此,我们正在积极研究增值的最佳方式,为股东带来回报的最佳方法是什么。因此,我认为我们正在积极地做这件事,所以我不确定你的问题是否明确。”
Given the Board's refusal to engage with us regarding our proposal or conduct a process to explore whether other parties may have an interest in transacting with Whitestone, Mr. Holeman's comments are at best a naïve sidestep to the question, and at worst a downright lie to shareholders.
鉴于董事会拒绝就我们的提案与我们接触,也拒绝开展程序来探讨其他各方是否可能有兴趣与怀特斯通进行交易,因此霍尔曼的言论充其量只能天真地回避这个问题,最坏的情况是对股东的彻头彻尾的谎言。
We have heard from a number of other shareholders that they are supportive of a potential transaction and share our frustration with the Whitestone Board. We believe some of these shareholders have reached out to Whitestone directly to demand answers. Unfortunately, it appears that the Whitestone Board has ignored these concerns and refused to engage with them, just as it has consistently refused to engage with MCB.
我们从其他一些股东那里听说,他们支持一项潜在的交易,并和我们一样对怀特斯通董事会感到沮丧。我们认为,其中一些股东已经直接联系了怀特斯通,要求答案。不幸的是,白石委员会似乎忽视了这些担忧,拒绝与之接触,就像它一直拒绝与McB接触一样。
As Whitestone's largest actively managed shareholder, with ownership of 4,690,000 shares representing 9.4% of Whitestone's common shares, we note the addition of Kristian M. Gathright and Donald A. Miller to the Whitestone Board. Ms. Gathright and Mr. Miller are two new and well-regarded independent trustees whom we hope will bring fresh perspective to the Board and ensure that the Whitestone Board acts in accordance with its fiduciary duties, including taking appropriate steps to maximize value for Whitestone shareholders.
作为怀特斯通最大的主动管理股东,拥有4,690,000股股票,占怀特斯通普通股的9.4%,我们注意到克里斯蒂安·加思赖特和唐纳德·A·米勒加入怀特斯通董事会。Gathright女士和Miller先生是两位备受推崇的新独立受托人,我们希望他们将为董事会带来全新的视角,并确保怀特斯通董事会按照其信托义务行事,包括采取适当措施为怀特斯通股东实现价值最大化。
The reputations and careers of these professionals, as well as the rest of the Board, are on the line, and we call on them to act in shareholders' best interests. We believe the inherent disadvantages of Whitestone as a standalone company, and the upside for shareholders from a well-run strategic review process, are obvious.
这些专业人士以及董事会其他成员的声誉和职业生涯都处于危险之中,我们呼吁他们为股东的最大利益行事。我们认为,Whitestone作为一家独立公司的固有缺点,以及良好的战略审查过程给股东带来的好处,是显而易见的。
As we have said from the onset of this process, our interests are aligned with other Whitestone shareholders. Whitestone shareholders deserve a board that is committed to considering all opportunities to maximize value. If the Whitestone Board continues its pattern of delay and entrenchment, MCB believes the entire Board should be removed at the next annual meeting of shareholders.
正如我们在这一过程一开始所说的那样,我们的利益与其他怀特斯通股东一致。Whitestone的股东理应有一个致力于考虑所有机会实现价值最大化的董事会。如果怀特斯通董事会继续其拖延和巩固的模式,McB认为,应在下次年度股东大会上罢免整个董事会。
While we are withdrawing our proposal at this time, we remain a significant shareholder of the company and will continue to consider all options available to MCB and other Whitestone shareholders to ensure that the Board upholds its responsibilities.
尽管我们目前正在撤回提案,但我们仍然是公司的重要股东,并将继续考虑向McB和其他Whitestone股东提供的所有选择,以确保董事会履行其职责。
Sincerely,
真诚地,
/s/ P. David Bramble
P. David Bramble, Managing Partner
/s/ P. David Bramble
P. David Bramble,管理合伙人
Additional Materials
Additional materials regarding the proposed transaction, including a letter sent to Whitestone's Board on October 9, 2024 detailing MCB's enhanced proposal, are available at .
其他材料
有关拟议交易的其他材料,包括2024年10月9日致怀特斯通董事会的一封信,详细说明了MCB的增强提案,请访问。
Advisors
MCB has engaged Vinson & Elkins LLP as lead counsel and Wells Fargo is serving as financial advisor to MCB.
顾问
McB已聘请文森和埃尔金斯律师事务所担任首席法律顾问,富国银行聘请文森和埃尔金斯律师事务所担任McB的财务顾问。
About MCB Real Estate
Founded in 2007, MCB Real Estate is a community-centric, privately held institutional investment management firm headquartered in Baltimore, Maryland. MCB boasts a nationwide portfolio of $3 Billion Assets Under Management totaling approximately 15 million square-feet. of industrial, office, retail, mixed-use, multi-family and life sciences properties with almost four million square-feet in its development pipeline. The firm offers a seamlessly integrated suite of commercial real estate investment services, including development, construction, property management, asset management, acquisitions, and legal expertise, thus ensuring comprehensive support throughout every stage of an asset's lifecycle. .
关于 McB Real Estate
McB Real Estate成立于2007年,是一家以社区为中心的私人控股机构投资管理公司,总部位于马里兰州巴尔的摩。McB在全国范围内拥有30亿美元的资产组合,总面积约为1500万平方英尺。包括工业、办公、零售、混合用途、多户住宅和生命科学地产,其开发面积接近400万平方英尺。该公司提供无缝集成的商业房地产投资服务套件,包括开发、施工、物业管理、资产管理、收购和法律专业知识,从而确保在资产生命周期的每个阶段提供全面支持。
Media Contacts
Andrew Siegel / Lucas Pers / Lyle Weston
Joele Frank, Wilkinson Brimmer Katcher
212-355-4449
媒体联系人
安德鲁·西格尔/卢卡斯·珀斯/莱尔·韦斯顿
乔尔·弗兰克,Wilkinson Brimmer Katcher
212-355-4449
SOURCE MCB Real Estate
来源 McB Real Estate