MCB Withdraws Proposal to Acquire Whitestone Due to Whitestone Board's Entrenchment and Refusal to Engage
MCB Withdraws Proposal to Acquire Whitestone Due to Whitestone Board's Entrenchment and Refusal to Engage
Calls on Independent Trustees of Whitestone to Initiate Strategic Review Process to Maximize Value for Whitestone Shareholders
呼籲whitestone的獨立受託人啓動戰略審查流程,以最大化whitestone股東的價值
Reminds Trustees of the Whitestone Board's Fiduciary Duties
提醒whitestone董事會的受託人其信託義務
BALTIMORE, Nov. 18, 2024 /PRNewswire/ -- MCB Real Estate ("MCB"), a leading commercial real estate developer and investment management firm with a diverse nationwide portfolio and approximately $3 billion in AUM, today sent a letter to the Board of Trustees of Whitestone REIT (NYSE: WSR) ("Whitestone") withdrawing MCB's previously announced proposal to acquire the company.
巴爾的摩,2024年11月18日 /PRNewswire/ -- MCb房地產業("MCB"),是一家領先的商業房地產開發和投資管理公司,擁有多樣化的全國性投資組合,資產管理約30億今日,今天向whitestone reit (紐交所代碼:WSR)("whitestone")的受託人委員會發送了一封信,撤回MCB之前宣佈的收購該公司的提議。
MCB sent the following letter to the Whitestone Board:
MCb向whitestone董事會發送了以下信件:
November 18, 2024
2024年11月18日
Board of Trustees
C/O David K. Holeman
Whitestone REIT
2600 S. Gessner Rd, Suite 500
Houston, TX 77063
董事會
收件人:David k. Holeman
Whitestone reit
2600 S. Gessner Rd,Suite 500
Houston, TX 77063
Dear Whitestone REIT Board of Trustees:
致Whitestone REIt董事會:
MCB Real Estate ("MCB" or "we") delivered an attractive, fully-financed proposal to the Whitestone Board to acquire Whitestone for $15 per share in an all-cash transaction. Our proposal would maximize value to Whitestone's shareholders, delivering immediate and certain value in the form of a 14.5% premium to Whitestone's share price prior to our initial proposal on June 3, 2024, and a 61.8% premium to Whitestone's unaffected share price prior to the rumored Fortress proposal on October 26, 2023. We have made repeated efforts to engage with the Whitestone Board over the last several months, but each of those attempts has been summarily rebuffed. The Board's refusal to grant due diligence, engage in any meaningful discussions, or commence a strategic alternatives process is not consistent with its duties and indicates a boardroom culture of entrenchment.
MCb 房地產業("MCB" 或 "我們")向 whitestone reit 董事會提交了一項吸引人的全額融資提案,計劃以每股15美元的現金交易收購 whitestone。我們的提案將最大化對 whitestone 股東的價值,以14.5%的溢價提供立即且確定的價值,溢價基於我們在2024年6月3日首次提議前的 whitestone 股價,以及61.8%的溢價基於2023年10月26日關於 Fortress 提議前的 whitestone 未受影響股價。我們在過去幾個月裏多次努力與 whitestone 董事會建立聯繫,但這些嘗試都被毫無保留地拒絕。董事會拒絕進行盡職調查、參與任何有意義的討論或啓動戰略替代方案的過程,這與其職責不符,並表明了董事會內部的固守文化。
While we continue to believe our proposal is the best path forward for shareholders, our attempts to engage have been rebuffed at every turn, so we are withdrawing our proposal to acquire Whitestone at this time.
儘管我們仍然相信我們的提案是對股東最好的前進道路,但我們的接觸嘗試在每一個環節都遭到了拒絕,因此我們現在撤回收購 whitestone 的提案。
This is not a decision taken lightly. We are disappointed and disturbed at the Board's intransigence, entrenchment and apparent self-interest. The Company's recent public comments make it painfully clear that the Board is not open-minded or even willing to give real consideration to opportunities to advance shareholders' best interests.
這個決定並非輕率作出。我們對董事會的無動於衷、固守和明顯的自利感到失望和不安。公司最近的公開評論清楚地表明,董事會並非持開放態度,甚至不願真正考慮推進股東最佳利益的機會。
Just a few weeks ago, Whitestone defended its entrenched position with unsupported and unrealistic claims of Whitestone's greater hypothetical "intrinsic value." Notably, however, that value was not actually provided, proven or even explained. Whitestone also attempted to rationalize the Board's refusal to consider alternatives by relying on a period of stock price outperformance that was driven by multiple acquisition rumors and proposals, including ours, that inflated Whitestone's share price.
就在幾周前,whitestone 用無支持和不現實的聲明爲其固守的立場辯護,聲稱 whitestone 的假設"內在價值"更高。然而,值得注意的是,該價值並沒有實際提供、證明或甚至解釋。whitestone 還試圖通過依賴一段因多個收購傳聞和提議(包括我們的提議)而驅動的股價超出表現的時期來合理化董事會拒絕考慮其他方案的行爲,這提高了 whitestone 的股價。
When pressed on whether the Board is open to opportunities to enhance value on Whitestone's third quarter 2024 earnings call, Whitestone CEO David Holeman falsely asserted that the Board is actively looking at strategic options. Further, he seemingly didn't even understand what such a process to maximize value would actually entail. When asked, he said:
當被問及董事會是否願意迎接機會以提高 whitestone 第三季度2024年業績會的價值時,whitestone 首席執行官大衛·霍爾曼錯誤地聲稱董事會正在積極尋求戰略選項。此外,他似乎甚至不理解這樣的最大化價值過程到底需要什麼。當被問及時,他說:
"I would tell you that our board reviews the best things for shareholders all the time. So we are actively looking at what are the best ways to add value, what are the best ways to produce a return to our shareholders. So I think we are actively doing that just like we should, and so I'm not sure I'm clear with your question."
"我想告訴你,我們的董事會始終在審查股東的最佳利益。因此,我們積極尋找增加價值的最佳方式,以及爲我們的股東產生回報的最佳方式。所以我覺得我們正在積極地做這些,就像我們應該做的那樣,所以我不太確定你的問題我是否理解清楚。"
Given the Board's refusal to engage with us regarding our proposal or conduct a process to explore whether other parties may have an interest in transacting with Whitestone, Mr. Holeman's comments are at best a naïve sidestep to the question, and at worst a downright lie to shareholders.
鑑於董事會拒絕與我們就我們的提案進行溝通或進行流程以探索其他方是否有意與whitestone進行交易,霍爾曼先生的評論充其量只是對問題的天真迴避,最壞的情況則是對股東的徹頭徹尾的謊言。
We have heard from a number of other shareholders that they are supportive of a potential transaction and share our frustration with the Whitestone Board. We believe some of these shareholders have reached out to Whitestone directly to demand answers. Unfortunately, it appears that the Whitestone Board has ignored these concerns and refused to engage with them, just as it has consistently refused to engage with MCB.
我們聽到來自其他股東的意見,他們支持潛在交易並對whitestone董事會的行爲感到失望。我們相信其中一些股東直接聯繫了whitestone以要求答案。不幸的是,whitestone董事會似乎忽視了這些關注,拒絕與他們溝通,就像它始終拒絕與MCb溝通一樣。
As Whitestone's largest actively managed shareholder, with ownership of 4,690,000 shares representing 9.4% of Whitestone's common shares, we note the addition of Kristian M. Gathright and Donald A. Miller to the Whitestone Board. Ms. Gathright and Mr. Miller are two new and well-regarded independent trustees whom we hope will bring fresh perspective to the Board and ensure that the Whitestone Board acts in accordance with its fiduciary duties, including taking appropriate steps to maximize value for Whitestone shareholders.
作爲whitestone最大的主動管理股東,擁有4,690,000股股份,代表着whitestone普通股的9.4%,我們注意到克里斯蒂安·m·蓋斯賴特和唐納德·A·米勒加入whitestone董事會。蓋斯賴特女士和米勒先生是兩位新的、備受尊敬的獨立受託人,我們希望他們能夠爲董事會帶來新的視角,並確保whitestone董事會根據其信託責任採取適當步驟,以最大化整個whitestone股東的價值。
The reputations and careers of these professionals, as well as the rest of the Board, are on the line, and we call on them to act in shareholders' best interests. We believe the inherent disadvantages of Whitestone as a standalone company, and the upside for shareholders from a well-run strategic review process, are obvious.
這些專業人士以及其他董事會成員的聲譽和職業生涯都岌岌可危,我們呼籲他們以股東的最佳利益行事。我們相信whitestone作爲獨立公司的固有劣勢,以及進行良好戰略審查過程帶來的股東收益,顯而易見。
As we have said from the onset of this process, our interests are aligned with other Whitestone shareholders. Whitestone shareholders deserve a board that is committed to considering all opportunities to maximize value. If the Whitestone Board continues its pattern of delay and entrenchment, MCB believes the entire Board should be removed at the next annual meeting of shareholders.
正如我們從這一過程開始時所說的,我們的利益與其他whitestone股東是一致的。whitestone股東應得到一個致力於考慮所有機會以最大化價值的董事會。如果whitestone董事會繼續其拖延和鞏固的模式,MCb認爲整個董事會應在下次股東年度會議上被罷免。
While we are withdrawing our proposal at this time, we remain a significant shareholder of the company and will continue to consider all options available to MCB and other Whitestone shareholders to ensure that the Board upholds its responsibilities.
雖然我們此時撤回了提案,但我們仍然是公司的重要股東,將繼續考慮MCb和其他whitestone reit股東可用的所有壓力位,以確保董事會履行其職責。
Sincerely,
此致敬禮,
/s/ P. David Bramble
P. David Bramble, Managing Partner
/s/ P. David Bramble
P. David Bramble,董事合夥人
Additional Materials
Additional materials regarding the proposed transaction, including a letter sent to Whitestone's Board on October 9, 2024 detailing MCB's enhanced proposal, are available at .
其他材料
關於擬議交易的額外材料,包括2024年10月9日發送給whitestone董事會的信件,詳細說明了MCB的增強提案,已在此處提供。
Advisors
MCB has engaged Vinson & Elkins LLP as lead counsel and Wells Fargo is serving as financial advisor to MCB.
顧問
MCb已聘請Vinson & Elkins LLP作爲首席法律顧問,Wells Fargo作爲MCb的財務顧問。
About MCB Real Estate
Founded in 2007, MCB Real Estate is a community-centric, privately held institutional investment management firm headquartered in Baltimore, Maryland. MCB boasts a nationwide portfolio of $3 Billion Assets Under Management totaling approximately 15 million square-feet. of industrial, office, retail, mixed-use, multi-family and life sciences properties with almost four million square-feet in its development pipeline. The firm offers a seamlessly integrated suite of commercial real estate investment services, including development, construction, property management, asset management, acquisitions, and legal expertise, thus ensuring comprehensive support throughout every stage of an asset's lifecycle. .
關於MCb房地產業
成立於2007年,MCb房地產業是一家以社區爲中心的,私人持有的機構投資管理公司,總部位於馬里蘭州巴爾的摩。MCb擁有全國範圍內的$30億資產管理組合,總面積約爲1500萬平方英尺,涵蓋工業、辦公、零售、混合用途、多家庭和生命科學物業,其中開發管道中幾乎有400萬平方英尺。該公司提供無縫整合的商業地產投資服務,包括開發、施工、物業管理、資產管理、收購和法律專業知識,從而確保在資產生命週期的每個階段都提供全面支持。
Media Contacts
Andrew Siegel / Lucas Pers / Lyle Weston
Joele Frank, Wilkinson Brimmer Katcher
212-355-4449
媒體聯繫人
安德魯·西格爾 / 盧卡斯·佩爾斯 / 萊爾·韋斯頓
Joele Frank, Wilkinson Brimmer Katcher
212-355-4449
SOURCE MCB Real Estate
資訊MCb房地產