Old Dominion Freight Line Inc (NASDAQ:ODFL) just reaffirmed its status as the gold standard in less-than-truckload (LTL) freight, according to JPMorgan analyst Brian Ossenbeck, who recently pored over insights from the 2024 Mastio Survey.

Old Dominion's Playbook: The Industry's Gold Standard For 15 Years

The survey, with feedback from roughly 1,600 shippers, showcases Old Dominion's dominance in an industry where rivals are scrambling to catch up.

Despite the buzz around newer strategies, Ossenbeck's analysis indicates that Old Dominion still has a substantial lead. Peers like XPO Inc. (NYSE:XPO) and Saia Inc (NASDAQ:SAIA) may be adopting aspects of Old Dominion's "playbook". They've been prioritizing service, improving network efficiency, and leveraging pricing power. But even after implementing these strategies, they've only narrowed the gap by 7%.

Ossenbeck puts it simply—executing Old Dominion's playbook is easier said than done.

Read Also: Old Dominion Freight Line Q3: Misses On Earnings And Revenue As Economic Headwinds Weigh

ArcBest, XPO Make Gains, While TForce, Saia Lag

Among the pack, ArcBest Corp (NASDAQ:ARCB) and XPO made notable strides in 2024.

ArcBest showed the largest service improvement, with strong gains in on-time pickup and delivery, key metrics for shippers.

XPO, with its LTL 2.0 strategy, also achieved robust performance gains, especially with smaller shippers. Meanwhile, Estes held steady, maintaining a high service level but not outpacing peers in improvement.

At the other end of the spectrum, TForce Freight is struggling with cost efficiencies and service expectations. Saia, despite a network expansion, saw its service performance slip, a trend Ossenbeck expects to stabilize in the coming year.

And then there's FedEx Freight – which has the second-slowest performance improvement among national carriers.

For 15 years running, Old Dominion has been the reigning champ in LTL freight, while peers have been taking notes. According to Ossenbeck, OD's mastery in service, pricing, and network efficiency keeps it miles ahead – leaving everyone else playing catch-up.

• Powell Dismisses Talk Of Resignation After Trump Victory, Says 'Policy Is Still Restrictive'

Photo: Jon Tetzlaff/Shutterstock.com