MCB Calls on Whitestone to Maximize Shareholder Value
MCB Calls on Whitestone to Maximize Shareholder Value
The Whitestone Board Has Summarily Rejected and Refused to Engage Regarding MCB's Improved $15.00 per Share All-Cash Proposal, which would Deliver a 14.5% Premium to Whitestone Shareholders
Whitestone董事会已经概括拒绝并拒绝就MCB改良的每股15.00美元现金提议进行接触,该提议将为Whitestone股东提供14.5%的溢价。
MCB Urges the Whitestone Board and Management Team to Cease their Entrenchment Tactics
and Answer Shareholders' Questions
MCb敦促Whitestone董事会和管理团队停止他们的设防策略
并回答股东们的问题
MCB Calls on Whitestone Shareholders to Make their Voices Heard;
MCb号召Whitestone股东发出自己的声音;
Visit for More Information
访问 获取更多信息
BALTIMORE, Oct. 31, 2024 /PRNewswire/ -- MCB Real Estate ("MCB"), a leading commercial real estate developer and investment management firm with a diverse nationwide portfolio and approximately $3 billion in AUM, today issued the following statement regarding its proposal to acquire Whitestone REIT (NYSE: WSR) ("Whitestone") for $15.00 per share in cash:
巴尔的摩,2024年10月31日/美通社/--MCb房地产(“MCB”),一家领先的商业房地产开发商和投资管理公司,具有各种多样化的全国资产组合,约30亿美元的资产管理规模(AUm),今天就其提议收购Whitestone REIt(纽交所:WSR)(“Whitestone”)每股15.00美元现金发表以下声明:
MCB stands ready to deliver immediate and certain value to Whitestone shareholders. Our proposal is compelling by all reasonable metrics, reflecting a 14.5% premium to Whitestone's share price prior to our initial proposal on June 3, 2024, and a 61.8% premium to Whitestone's unaffected share price prior to the rumored Fortress proposal on October 26, 2023. Despite an attractive proposal and our repeated attempts to engage over the last several months, the Whitestone Board has steadfastly refused to seriously consider our all-cash proposal.
MCb已准备好向Whitestone股东提供即时和确定的价值。我们的提议在所有合理的衡量标准下都非常吸引人,相比于2024年6月3日我们首次提议之前Whitestone的股价,提供14.5%的溢价,并相比于2023年10月26日有传言的要塞提议之前Whitestone未受影响的股价,提供61.8%的溢价。尽管有一份有吸引力的提议,以及我们过去几个月不断尝试进行交流,Whitestone董事会仍坚决拒绝认真考虑我们的全现金提议。
In its rejection, Whitestone has conveniently chosen a time period of total shareholder return that includes multiple acquisition rumors and proposals, as well as MCB acquiring 4,690,000 shares on the open market. In the time between January 18, 2022, when current Whitestone management took over, and October 25, 2023, the day prior to the rumored Fortress proposal, Whitestone delivered total shareholder returns of 0.1%. Since October 25, 2023, Whitestone has delivered total shareholder returns of 57.7%, driven by the rumored Fortress Proposal, MCB's acquisition of shares starting on May 7, 2024, and two acquisition proposals from MCB.
在拒绝中,Whitestone方便地选择了一个包括多个收购传言和提议的总股东回报周期,以及MCb在开放市场上收购469万股的时期。从2022年1月18日当前Whitestone管理团队接管以来,到2023年10月25日--即传言要塞提议的前一天,Whitestone的总股东回报率为0.1%。自2023年10月25日起,Whitestone的总股东回报率为57.7%,这归功于传言要塞提议,MCB于2024年5月7日开始收购股份,以及MCb的两个收购提议。
We have heard from other shareholders that they are supportive of a potential transaction and share our frustration with the Whitestone Board. The Board's refusal to grant due diligence, engage in any meaningful discussions, or commence a strategic alternatives process is not consistent with its duties and indicates that the Board is entrenched. Whitestone shareholders deserve answers, and MCB encourages Whitestone to address the following questions on its earnings call this morning, so that shareholders can have all the facts regarding Whitestone's refusal to engage or present a compelling path to maximize shareholder value as a public company.
我们已经听到其他股东表示对潜在交易持支持,并与Whitestone董事会的沮丧感共鸣。董事会拒绝给予尽职调查、参与任何有意义的讨论或启动战略替代流程,与其职责不符,并表明董事会根深蒂固。Whitestone股东应得到答案,MCb鼓励Whitestone在今早的业绩会上回答以下问题,以便股东能获得关于Whitestone拒绝参与或呈现最大化股东价值的引人注目路径的所有事实。
- What does the Whitestone Board believe the Company's net asset value (NAV) to be?
- Whitestone has implied its NAV and discounted cash flow (DCF) based on its internal forecasts indicate a higher "intrinsic value" than provided by MCB's improved proposal – what are those forecasts?
- Why not share the NAV and DCF forecasts with MCB or other potential counterparties?
- What purchase price would the Board need to see in order to grant due diligence?
- How can Whitestone's Board reasonably credit the management team for the 60% total shareholder returns since the management team was appointed, considering that total shareholder returns during the period prior to takeover interest were almost zero?
- Given that MCB's purchases represent a significant portion of WSR's trading volume over the course of 2024, what is Whitestone's plan to maintain its share price if MCB withdraws its offer and liquidates its position?
- Has Whitestone engaged with independent advisors or formed a committee of the board to evaluate MCB's proposal or explore strategic alternatives to maximize value? If not, why not?
- Is Whitestone's Board open to running a formal process to evaluate strategic alternatives?
- How can the Board justify its refusal to engage with qualified buyers, such as Fortress and MCB?
- Does Whitestone recognize its continued underperformance versus its peers, and how does management intend to address Whitestone's high cost of capital, high cost of borrowing and apparent inability to raise new equity?
- Will the Whitestone Board and management team spend shareholders' capital defending against a proxy contest again this year? How can that be justified and why is that preferable to engaging with well-capitalized potential acquirers?
- Whitestone董事会认为公司的净资产价值(NAV)是多少?
- Whitestone已暗示其基于内部预测的NAV和折现现金流量(DCF)表明其更高的“内在价值”高于MCB改进提议提供的价值-那些预测是什么?
- 为什么不与MCb或其他潜在的交易对手分享NAV和DCF的预测?
- 董事会需要看到什么购买价格才会同意进行尽职调查?
- 考虑到在接管兴趣之前的时期股东总回报几乎为零,Whitestone董事会如何合理地信任管理团队在任命后的60%股东总回报?
- 考虑到MCB的购买在2024年期间占WSR交易量的重要部分,如果MCb撤回其报价并清算头寸,Whitestone如何计划维持其股价?
- Whitestone是否与独立顾问进行了交流或成立了董事会委员会来评估MCB的提议或探索最大化价值的战略替代方案?如果没有,为什么?
- Whitestone董事会是否愿意开展正式流程,以评估战略选择?
- 董事会如何证明其拒绝与Fortress和MCB等合格买家接触的决定?
- Whitestone是否意识到与同行持续表现不佳,管理层如何打算解决Whitestone高资本成本、高借款成本和明显无法筹集新股权的问题?
- Whitestone董事会和管理团队会花费股东的资本来捍卫今年的代理竞选吗?这样做如何合理,为何与实力雄厚的潜在收购者接触不可取?
Whitestone Third Quarter 2024 Conference Call Details
Whitestone第三季度2024年电话会议详情
MCB urges Whitestone shareholders to join Whitestone's Third Quarter 2024 earnings conference call to listen to the Whitestone management team's responses to these and other questions. P. David Bramble, Managing Partner of MCB, will join the call and attempt to ask a question, but based on Whitestone's refusal to engage to date, MCB expects to be rebuffed, again, and is therefore calling on others in the investment community to demand the answers shareholders deserve.
MCb敦促Whitestone股东参加Whitestone第三季度2024年业绩会,听取Whitestone管理团队对这些及其他问题的回答。MCb的管理合伙人P. David Bramble将参加会议并尝试提问,但基于Whitestone迄今拒绝合作,MCb预计将再次被拒绝,因此呼吁投资社区其他人士要求股东应得的回答。
Dial-in number for domestic participants: 1-877-407-0784
Dial-in number for international participants: 1-201-689-8560
Passcode: 13742564
国内参与者拨打电话号码:1-877-407-0784
国际参与者拨打电话号码:1-201-689-8560
密码:13742564
A live webcast of Whitestone's conference call can be accessed at
whitestone的业绩会实况网络广播可在 下方链接 中收看
Additional Materials
其他材料
Additional materials regarding the proposed transaction, including a letter sent to Whitestone's Board on October 9, 2024 detailing MCB's enhanced proposal, are available at .
关于拟议交易的其他材料,包括2024年10月9日发送给Whitestone董事会的信函,详细说明了MCB的增强提议,可在 此处链接 查看。
Advisors
顾问
MCB has engaged Vinson & Elkins LLP as lead counsel in connection with the transaction. Wells Fargo is serving as financial advisor to MCB.
MCb已委托Vinson & Elkins LLP作为本次交易的主要律师。富国银行正担任MCb的财务顾问。
About MCB Real Estate
关于MCb房地产
Founded in 2007, MCB Real Estate is a community-centric, privately held institutional investment management firm headquartered in Baltimore, Maryland. MCB boasts a nationwide portfolio of $3 Billion Assets Under Management totaling approximately 15 million square-feet. of industrial, office, retail, mixed-use, multi-family and life sciences properties with almost four million square-feet in its development pipeline. The firm offers a seamlessly integrated suite of commercial real estate investment services, including development, construction, property management, asset management, acquisitions, and legal expertise, thus ensuring comprehensive support throughout every stage of an asset's lifecycle. .
成立于2007年,MCb房地产是一家以社区为中心的,总部位于马里兰州巴尔的摩的私人持有的机构投资管理公司。 MCb拥有一个总值约30亿资产管理的全国性投资组合,总计约1500万平方英尺。的工业、办公、零售、综合用途、多功能家庭和生命科学属性,其发展管道中几乎有四百万平方英尺。 该公司提供一系列无缝整合的商业房地产投资服务,包括开发、建筑、物业管理、资产管理、收购和法律专业知识,从而确保资产生命周期的每个阶段都得到全面支持。
Media Contacts
媒体联系人
Andrew Siegel / Lucas Pers / Lyle Weston
Joele Frank, Wilkinson Brimmer Katcher
212-355-4449
安德鲁·西格尔/卢卡斯·佩尔斯/丽尔·韦斯顿
Joele Frank, Wilkinson Brimmer Katcher
212-355-4449
SOURCE MCB Real Estate
资讯MCb房地产