The company's poor ROCE and the increase in capital employed indicate that the business isn't deploying the funds into high return investments. The underlying trends do not inspire confidence and there may be better chances of finding a multi-bagger elsewhere.

Analysts laud Montauk Renewables for reinvesting profits, sparking robust earnings growth. They envision the company maintaining this growth, promising future despite stock decline.

The VP's share sale, executed at a price exceeding current value, might be seen negatively. Despite insider's significant stakes in Montauk Renewables aligning with shareholder interests, the absence of recent insider buying doesn't inspire confidence in the company's future.

Montauk Renewables is generating insufficient returns despite reinvestment of capital. The company seems unable to deploy funds into high-return investments, raising doubts over its investment strategy and growth potential.