American-style Options vs European-style Options: Key Differences Explained

Views 629Jul 9, 2024

In the world of options trading, understanding the distinctions between American and European options is crucial. From this guide, learn about their features, differences, and how you might trade them more effectively.

Understanding American-style options vs European-style options

When it comes to American options vs. European options, the main difference lies with their exercise rights and assignment. It's also important to note that these two option types can both be bought and/or sold at any time before expiration. Here's some more details.

American options grant holders the right to exercise their options at any point before expiration, offering flexibility in potentially capitalizing on market movements, which makes these options come with higher premiums while European options only allow exercise at expiration, limiting flexibility to capitalize on short-term fluctuations but offering lower premiums. Traders must assess their risk tolerance and trading strategies when choosing between the two.

What are American-style and European-style options?

American and European options are types of financial contracts granting the holder the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell an underlying asset at a predetermined price within a specified timeframe. American options generally provide the holder flexibility through their ability to exercise at any time before expiration, while European options only permit exercise at expiration.

American-style options

American options provide flexibility for both buyers and sellers. Buyers can exercise their options before expiration, allowing quick reactions to market changes and potential profits from favorable price movements. Sellers face numerous risks with an early exercise, including opportunity cost (losing interest that could be earned on their money), undergoing the impact of a potential risk or reward of the overall position, and uncertainty of share value.

For instance, a trader buying an American call option with a strike price of $50 on a stock currently trading at $55 may pay a premium of $5. If the market price rises to $60, the trader can exercise the option, and sell the shares immediately, earning a net profit of about $10 per share - the premium paid for the call option/s plus any commissions and fees.

European-style options

European options offer relatively more simplicity for both buyers and sellers. They only allow exercise at expiration, simplifying decision-making and resulting generally in lower premiums than American options.

For instance, a trader purchasing a European call option with a strike price of $50 may pay a premium of $4. However, they cannot exercise the option until expiration, regardless of any favorable market movements before then. However, keep in mind that European-style options can still be closed out early if the price has appreciated in value or to limit further losses. Traders who prefer straightforward trading when compared to American-style options and are willing to forego early exercise rights may choose European options.

commission-free options trading on moomoo

Key differences between European and American Options

European and American options differ in key aspects. American options offer holders the flexibility to exercise at any time before expiration, while European options only offer the opportunity to exercise at expiration. European options commonly settle in cash at expiration, whereas American options may settle in cash or take delivery of the underlying asset, depending on the option's terms and the nature of the underlying asset. Additionally, the settlement price for European options relies on the underlying asset's expiration price, while American options may vary based on exercise timing.

Exercise Rights

American options provide holders with the right to exercise the option at any time before expiration, offering flexibility. This feature provides traders with potentially greater control over their positions and the ability to adjust their strategies as market conditions change. However, is not generally beneficial to exercise options early as you can lose any extrinsic (time) value. An investor may choose to do so in certain instances, such as in relation to dividend dates or with deep in-the-money options.

In contrast, European options only permit exercise at expiration, limiting flexibility and simplifying decision-making for traders.

Cash Settlement

European options typically settle in cash at expiration where the option holder receives the cash value of the option's intrinsic value. This cash settlement eliminates the need for physical delivery of the underlying asset, streamlining the settlement process. Keep in mind that index options are European-style options and will therefore undergo a cash settlement.

American options result in either cash settlement or physical delivery of the underlying asset. There are instances when the underlying shares from the option contract may not be delivered. This can occur if the holder submits a Do Not Exercise (DNE) within the appropriate timeframe or they don't have sufficient funds in the account to support the exercise.

This flexibility may help traders to choose an appropriate settlement method based on their trading objectives and market conditions.

Settlement Price

For American options, the settlement price may vary depending on whether the option is exercised early. Options holders can choose to exercise their option whenever they believe the market conditions are most favorable, up until the expiration date. This means the settlement price is essentially the market price of the underlying asset at the time of exercise.

The settlement price for European options is determined at the close of trading on the expiration date. Since these options can only be exercised at expiration, the relevant market's closing price for the underlying asset is used as the settlement price. This is a more standardized approach, as all exercises of European options at expiration will use the same final market price to settle.

American-style options vs European-style options: What's the difference?

	American-style options	European-style options
Underlying assets	Typically available for individual stocks, commodities, and ETFs	Commonly used for index options
Exercise Rights	Can be exercised at any time before expiration	Can only be exercised at the expiration date
Settlement	Settlement involves cash or physical delivery, depending on the contract	Typically settled in cash at expiration
Settlement Price	Settlement price vary based on exercise timing	Settlement price based on the market price of the underlying asset
Premiums	Generally higher premiums due to their early exercise advantage	Often lower premiums due to limited exercise rights
Popularity	Widely traded due to flexibility, adaptability and underlying assets	Traded less compared to American options
Risk	Higher potential risk due to early exercise rights	Reduced risk exposure due to lack of early exercise
Hedging	Offers more flexibility to hedge against price movements because of their ability to be exercised any time up to their expiration	Offers hedging against changes in financial indices Because these can only be exercised at expiration, they are limited in hedging for specific timelines. European options are generally less expensive due to their reduced flexibility, potentially offering a cost-effective hedging solution for investors with a clear view on market direction leading up to the option's expiration date or those potentially seeking a lower initial cost.
Trading	May be appropriate for those desiring more contract and timing flexibility as well as volatile markets	May be appropriate for trading straightforward, time-specific hedges, providing a more calculated approach to managing financial risk.